The best protein soda overall in this roundup is Bucked Up Peach Mango, which pairs 25g of whey isolate with zero sugar for shoppers who want more protein per can. For a lower-protein, lower-calorie alternative, Livvy’s variety pack offers three flavors, 15g protein, and 80 calories; Premier Protein Black Cherry is another straightforward 15g option. The main tradeoffs are protein amount versus calories and sweetness, along with whether you want a single flavor or a variety pack. I compare all 14 options by their stated nutrition, formats, and flavor choices below. Read on for the full breakdown and a guide to choosing a can that suits your tastes and routine.
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Key Takeaways
- Bucked Up leads on protein per can: Its listed 25g whey isolate gives it an advantage for shoppers prioritizing protein, while the single-flavor 12-packs offer less variety than mixed packs.
- Livvy stands out for lighter variety: Its three-flavor pack lists 15g protein and 80 calories per can, making it a different proposition from Bucked Up’s higher-protein, zero-sugar lineup.
- Variety packs reduce flavor commitment: Gym Soda, Livvy, and Proda offer mixed-flavor formats, while most Bucked Up choices come as a 12-pack of one flavor.
- Pack size changes the trial experience: Clean Simple Eats is listed as a four-pack, a smaller commitment than the many 12-can options; check the product listing for current serving and nutrition details.
- Protein amounts vary widely: The listed range runs from Proda’s 10g to Bucked Up’s 25g, so compare protein per can with your intended serving rather than assuming all protein sodas are alike.
| protein soda | Caffeine | Protein | Pack size | Sugar |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bucked Up Lightly Carbonated P | Caffeine-free | 25 g per can | 12 cans | — |
| Gym Soda Sparkling Clear Prote | 45 mg in cola; caffeine-free in grape and grapefruit citrus | 15 g per can | 12 cans | 3 g per can |
| Bucked Up Lightly Carbonated P | None | 25 g per can | 12 cans | 0 g |
| Livvy Protein Soda Variety Pac | Caffeine-free | 15 g per can | 12 cans | Low; exact amount unspecified |
| Bucked Up Lightly Carbonated P | Caffeine-free | 25 g per can | 12 cans | Zero sugar |
| Bucked Up Lightly Carbonated P | Caffeine free | 25 g per can | 12 cans | Zero sugar |
| Bucked Up Lightly Carbonated P | Caffeine free | 25 g per can | 12 cans | Zero sugar |
| Bucked Up Lightly Carbonated P | Caffeine free | 25 g per can | 12 cans | Zero sugar |
| Clean Simple Eats Clear Protei | — | 20 g per serving | 4 cans | — |
| Bucked Up Lightly Carbonated P | Caffeine free | 25 g per can | 12 cans | Zero sugar |
| Proda Protein Soda Variety Pac | Caffeine-free | 10g complete whey protein per serving | — | 0g |
| Bucked Up Lightly Carbonated P | None | — | — | 0g |
| SkyPop Protein Soda | Caffeine-free | — | 12 cans | 0g |
| Premier Protein Sparkling Prot | Caffeine-free | 15g per can | 12 cans | 3g per 12 oz can |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Bucked Up Lightly Carbonated Protein Soda, Peach Mango, 25g Whey Isolate, Zero Sugar, 12-Pack, 16 oz Cans
I’d put this Bucked Up Peach Mango near the top for buyers who want a substantial protein serving in a soda-style drink: each 16-ounce can supplies 25 g of whey isolate, compared with the 15 g in Gym Soda’s smaller cans and Livvy’s variety pack. It also has zero sugar and zero carbs, and its caffeine-free formula works for people who want to keep stimulants out of a post-workout drink. The tradeoff is the format: light carbonation may not sit well for everyone, and whey makes it unsuitable for people avoiding dairy. Its single flavor offers less variety than Gym Soda or Livvy, but the 12-can shelf-stable pack is a practical fit for stocking a regular routine.
Pros:- 25 g of whey protein isolate per can
- Zero sugar and zero carbs
- Caffeine-free
- Shelf-stable 12-pack for convenient stocking
Cons:- Contains whey, so it is not suitable for people avoiding dairy
- Light carbonation may bother people sensitive to fizzy drinks
- Single-flavor pack offers less variety than Gym Soda or Livvy
Best for: Whey-consuming athletes who want 25 g of protein per can without sugar, carbs, or caffeine.
Not ideal for: People avoiding dairy or carbonation, and buyers who want multiple flavors in one pack.
- Flavor:Peach Mango
- Protein:25 g per can
- Protein type:Whey protein isolate
- Can size:16 oz
- Pack size:12 cans
- Sugar and carbohydrates:Zero sugar; zero carbs
- Caffeine:Caffeine-free
- Carbonation:Lightly carbonated
- Storage:Shelf-stable
Our verdict“Choose Peach Mango if your priority is a 25 g, zero-sugar protein soda and you are comfortable with whey and light carbonation.”
Gym Soda Sparkling Clear Protein Drink, 15g Protein, 12 oz, Variety Pack, 12 Cans
Gym Soda is the most flexible choice here for someone who tires of a single flavor: its 12 cans are split across cola, grape, and grapefruit citrus. At 15 g of clear whey protein per 12-ounce can, it provides less protein than either 25 g Bucked Up option, but its smaller serving may suit buyers who want a lighter drink. Each can has 80 calories and 3 g of sugar; that makes it a different fit from Bucked Up Peach Mango, which lists zero sugar and zero carbs. The caffeine split also matters: cola contains 45 mg, while the other two flavors are caffeine-free. Added lion’s mane and L-theanine distinguish the formula, though they may not matter to buyers focused only on protein.
Pros:- Three distinct flavors in one 12-can pack
- 15 g of clear whey protein per can
- 80 calories per can
- Grape and grapefruit citrus flavors are caffeine-free
Cons:- Provides less protein per can than the Bucked Up 25 g drinks
- Contains 3 g of sugar per can
- Cola contains caffeine, so the full pack is not caffeine-free
Best for: People who want several soda-inspired flavors and are comfortable choosing between caffeinated and caffeine-free cans.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking 25 g of protein per can, zero sugar, or a fully caffeine-free pack.
- Protein:15 g per can
- Protein source:Clear whey protein isolate
- Can size:12 oz
- Pack size:12 cans
- Flavors:Cola, grape, grapefruit citrus
- Calories:80 per can
- Sugar:3 g per can
- Caffeine:45 mg in cola; caffeine-free in grape and grapefruit citrus
- Additional ingredients:Lion’s mane and L-theanine
Our verdict“Pick Gym Soda if flavor variety matters more than maximizing protein or keeping every can sugar- and caffeine-free.”
Bucked Up Lightly Carbonated Protein Soda – Frosted Lemonade, 25g Whey Isolate, 12‑Pack 16 oz Cans
Frosted Lemonade gives the high-protein Bucked Up format a citrus-leaning flavor direction, with 25 g of whey isolate in each 16-ounce can. Like Bucked Up Green Apple, it is lightly carbonated and caffeine-free; the listed details also describe it as zero sugar and low calorie. Compared with Gym Soda, it offers 10 g more protein per can, though it lacks Gym Soda’s mixed-flavor pack. That makes this a better match for someone who knows they want lemonade-style flavor and plans to keep the same drink on hand. The main caveats are familiar: carbonation can cause bloating for some people, and the product contains dairy-based whey. Calories are described only as low, without a specific figure, so buyers tracking exact amounts have less information.
Pros:- 25 g of whey isolate per 16-ounce can
- Zero sugar and described as low calorie
- Caffeine-free
- Shelf-stable 12-pack suited to stocking up
Cons:- Light carbonation may cause bloating for some people
- Contains whey, so it is not suitable for people avoiding dairy
- No exact calorie count is provided in the product details
Best for: Whey-consuming buyers who prefer a lemonade-style flavor and want a higher-protein, caffeine-free canned drink.
Not ideal for: People avoiding dairy or carbonation, or shoppers who need an exact calorie figure and multiple flavors per pack.
- Flavor:Frosted Lemonade
- Protein:25 g per can
- Protein type:Whey protein isolate
- Serving size:16 oz (473 ml)
- Pack size:12 cans
- Sugar:0 g
- Calories:Low; exact amount unspecified
- Caffeine:None
- Carbonation and storage:Lightly carbonated; shelf-stable
Our verdict“Choose Frosted Lemonade for a single-flavor citrus option with 25 g of protein, provided you accept whey and carbonation.”
Livvy Protein Soda Variety Pack – 12 Cans (Peach Mango, Blueberry Lemonade, Orange Guava), 15g Protein, 80 Calories, Low Sugar, Caffeine-Free
Livvy suits buyers who want fruit flavors without a caffeinated option mixed into the box. The pack includes Peach Mango, Blueberry Lemonade, and Orange Guava, and all are described as caffeine-free. Each can delivers 15 g of whey protein and 80 calories, making it closer to Gym Soda’s protein level than to the 25 g Bucked Up cans. Unlike Gym Soda, Livvy avoids a caffeinated cola flavor; unlike Bucked Up Green Apple, it offers three flavors rather than one. The tradeoff is that its sugar is listed only as low, not as zero, and the product may not satisfy someone expecting conventional soda taste. It is a handy ready-to-drink choice for flavor rotation, but still contains whey.
Pros:- Three fruit flavors in one pack
- 15 g of whey protein per can
- 80 calories per can
- Caffeine-free across the listed flavors
Cons:- Less protein per can than the Bucked Up 25 g options
- Sugar is described as low, not zero
- May not match the taste of traditional soda
Best for: People who want a caffeine-free, fruit-flavored variety pack with a moderate protein serving.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need 25 g of protein per can, require zero sugar, or avoid dairy-based whey.
- Protein:15 g per can
- Protein source:Whey protein
- Calories:80 per can
- Sugar:Low; exact amount unspecified
- Caffeine:Caffeine-free
- Flavors:Peach Mango, Blueberry Lemonade, Orange Guava
- Pack size:12 cans
- Format:Clear, sparkling, ready to drink
Our verdict“Choose Livvy if you want caffeine-free fruit variety and accept 15 g of whey protein with low rather than zero sugar.”
Bucked Up Lightly Carbonated Protein Soda, Green Apple, 25g Whey Isolate, Zero Sugar, 12 Pack, 16 oz Cans
Green Apple is a straightforward fit for buyers who want a crisp fruit flavor and a larger protein serving without a mixed box. Each 16-ounce can contains 25 g of whey isolate, with zero sugar and no caffeine. That puts it alongside Bucked Up Peach Mango and Frosted Lemonade on protein, while setting all three apart from the 15 g Gym Soda and Livvy options. The distinction here is flavor and format rather than nutrition: Green Apple comes as a 12-pack of lightly carbonated cans, so it is better for someone who already knows they enjoy this style than for a flavor sampler. The pack is shelf-stable and ready to drink, but carbonation may not suit everyone, and whey excludes buyers avoiding dairy.
Pros:- 25 g of whey protein isolate per can
- Zero sugar
- Caffeine-free
- Shelf-stable, ready-to-drink 12-pack
Cons:- Contains whey, so it is not suitable for people avoiding dairy
- Light carbonation may not suit people sensitive to fizzy drinks
- Single-flavor pack gives less variety than Gym Soda or Livvy
Best for: People who prefer green-apple flavor and want a caffeine-free, zero-sugar drink with 25 g of whey protein.
Not ideal for: Dairy-avoiding buyers, people sensitive to carbonation, or anyone seeking a multi-flavor pack.
- Brand:Bucked Up
- Flavor:Green Apple
- Protein:25 g per can
- Protein source:Whey protein isolate
- Can size:16 oz
- Pack size:12 cans
- Sugar:Zero sugar
- Caffeine:Caffeine-free
- Format and storage:Lightly carbonated, ready to drink, shelf-stable
Our verdict“Pick Green Apple if you want a 25 g, zero-sugar protein soda in one crisp fruit flavor and do not need variety.”
Bucked Up Lightly Carbonated Protein Soda, Rainbow Candy, 12 Pack, 16 oz Cans
Rainbow Candy gives the Bucked Up lineup its most confectionery-leaning profile, paired with 25 g of whey protein isolate in a large, 16-ounce can. Its light carbonation and clear texture offer a different feel from a traditional shake, while zero sugar and no caffeine make it suitable when you want protein without either. Compared with Clean Simple Eats Cherry Lime, this is the higher-protein, larger-pack option, but it doesn’t share that product’s stated naturally sweetened positioning or low-lactose description. The tradeoff is a flavor style that may appeal to candy fans but feel too sweet-tasting for buyers who prefer fruit-forward drinks. It also contains whey, so it isn’t a fit for people avoiding dairy-derived protein.
Pros:- Provides 25 g of whey protein isolate per can
- Zero sugar and caffeine free
- Light carbonation and clear texture differ from a conventional shake
- Convenient 12-pack of 16-ounce cans
Cons:- Contains whey protein, so it is not suitable for people avoiding dairy-derived protein
- Candy-inspired flavor may not suit shoppers who prefer subtler or tart fruit profiles
Best for: Protein-soda shoppers who prefer candy-inspired flavors and want 25 g of protein in a ready-to-drink can.
Not ideal for: People avoiding dairy-derived protein or shoppers who prefer tart, fruit-forward flavors over candy-style options.
- Flavor:Rainbow Candy
- Protein:25 g per can
- Protein source:Whey protein isolate
- Can size:16 oz
- Pack size:12 cans
- Sugar:Zero sugar
- Caffeine:Caffeine free
- Format:Lightly carbonated, ready to drink
Our verdict“Choose Rainbow Candy if you want a lightly fizzy, candy-style drink with 25 g of protein and are comfortable with whey.”
Bucked Up Lightly Carbonated Protein Soda, Cherry Limeade, 12-Pack of 16 oz Cans
Cherry Limeade is the Bucked Up pick for shoppers who want a recognizable fruit-and-citrus direction rather than the candy-leaning profile of Rainbow Candy. It delivers 25 g of whey protein isolate per 16-ounce can, with light carbonation, zero sugar, and no caffeine. That combination makes it an easy ready-to-drink choice after exercise or as a cold protein option during the day, without asking you to mix a shake. Compared with Clean Simple Eats Cherry Lime, Bucked Up provides more protein per can and comes in a 12-pack, while Clean Simple Eats specifies grass-fed whey and low lactose. The tradeoff is that this still contains whey and is not dairy-free; the supplied details also don’t specify a lactose level.
Pros:- Delivers 25 g of whey protein isolate per can
- Zero sugar and caffeine free
- Light carbonation makes it an alternative to a thick protein shake
- Includes 12 ready-to-drink 16-ounce cans
Cons:- Contains whey protein and is not dairy-free
- Lactose content is not specified in the provided product details
Best for: Buyers who want a citrus-and-cherry flavored protein soda, a full 25 g protein serving, and a larger ready-to-drink pack.
Not ideal for: People avoiding dairy or shoppers looking specifically for a low-lactose product with a stated lactose level.
- Flavor:Cherry Limeade
- Protein:25 g per can
- Protein type:Whey protein isolate
- Can size:16 oz
- Pack size:12 cans
- Sugar:Zero sugar
- Caffeine:Caffeine free
- Carbonation:Lightly carbonated
Our verdict“Pick Cherry Limeade if you want a citrus-forward Bucked Up option with 25 g of protein and don’t need a dairy-free formula.”
Bucked Up Lightly Carbonated Protein Soda, Orange Cream, 12-Pack
Orange Cream is the Bucked Up choice for shoppers drawn to a citrus-and-cream flavor rather than Cherry Limeade’s fruit-and-tart direction. Each 16-ounce can supplies 25 g of whey protein isolate, with zero sugar, no caffeine, and light carbonation. That makes it a substantial protein serving in a soda-style format, though it remains a large can rather than a small, casual drink. Compared with Clean Simple Eats Cherry Lime, this offers more protein per can and a 12-pack, while Clean Simple Eats lists grass-fed whey, low lactose, and no artificial flavors, sweeteners, or colors. The main compromise is dairy-derived protein, and the dessert-like flavor profile may be less appealing to buyers who want a crisp, tart soda taste.
Pros:- Provides 25 g of whey protein isolate per can
- Zero sugar and caffeine free
- Lightly carbonated format offers an alternative to a shake
- Comes in a 12-pack of 16-ounce cans
Cons:- Contains whey protein, so it is unsuitable for people avoiding dairy-derived protein
- Orange cream may feel too dessert-like for shoppers seeking a tart or crisp flavor
Best for: Shoppers who enjoy orange-and-cream flavors and want a high-protein, zero-sugar drink in a 12-pack.
Not ideal for: People avoiding whey or dairy-derived protein, and those who prefer tart or less dessert-like flavor profiles.
- Flavor:Orange Cream
- Protein:25 g per can
- Protein source:Whey protein isolate
- Can size:16 oz
- Pack size:12 cans
- Sugar:Zero sugar
- Caffeine:Caffeine free
- Carbonation:Lightly carbonated
Our verdict“Choose Orange Cream if a creamsicle-inspired taste matters more to you than a tart profile or dairy-free protein.”
Clean Simple Eats Clear Protein Soda, Cherry Lime, 4-Pack
Clean Simple Eats Cherry Lime stands apart from the Bucked Up cans by emphasizing its ingredient claims and a smaller four-can pack. It provides 20 g of grass-fed whey protein isolate per serving, with zero added sugar, low lactose, and no artificial flavors, sweeteners, or colors. That makes it a useful option for buyers who want a clear protein soda and value those specific formulation details more than the 25 g serving offered by Bucked Up Cherry Limeade. The lower protein amount and smaller pack are meaningful compromises, especially for shoppers stocking up or aiming for a larger protein serving in one can. It still contains whey, so low lactose does not make it dairy-free, and the product is not suitable for people avoiding dairy.
Pros:- Provides 20 g of grass-fed whey protein isolate per serving
- Contains zero added sugar
- Described as low in lactose
- No artificial flavors, sweeteners, or colors
Cons:- Provides less protein per serving than Bucked Up Cherry Limeade
- Four-can pack offers fewer cans than the 12-packs in the lineup
- Still contains whey and is not suitable for people avoiding dairy
Best for: Ingredient-conscious shoppers who want a smaller pack, grass-fed whey, and a clearly stated low-lactose formulation.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking 25 g of protein per can, a larger multi-can supply, or a dairy-free protein source.
- Flavor:Cherry Lime
- Pack size:4 cans
- Can size:16 oz
- Protein:20 g per serving
- Protein source:Grass-fed whey protein isolate
- Added sugar:0 g
- Lactose:Low
Our verdict“Choose Clean Simple Eats if its grass-fed, low-lactose, no-artificial-ingredient positioning matters more than a 25 g serving or a larger pack.”
Bucked Up Lightly Carbonated Protein Soda, 25g Whey Isolate, Zero Sugar, Caffeine Free, 12-Pack, 16 oz Cans, Banana Pineapple
Banana Pineapple brings a tropical fruit pairing to Bucked Up’s familiar formula: 25 g of whey protein isolate in a 16-ounce, lightly carbonated can, with zero sugar and no caffeine. It suits shoppers who want a fruitier alternative to the cream-style Orange Cream or candy-leaning Rainbow Candy, while keeping the same high-protein format and 12-can pack. That consistency is useful if flavor is the main point of difference you’re choosing between. The tradeoff is that a banana-and-pineapple profile is more specific than a straightforward citrus flavor, so it may be a less comfortable choice for anyone unsure about tropical combinations. Like the other Bucked Up options here, it uses whey and is not dairy-free.
Pros:- Provides 25 g of whey protein isolate per can
- Zero sugar and caffeine free
- Light carbonation makes it a soda-style alternative to a shake
- Ready-to-drink 12-pack of 16-ounce cans
Cons:- Contains whey protein, so it is not dairy-free
- Banana and pineapple make for a more specific flavor choice than straightforward citrus
Best for: Buyers who enjoy tropical fruit combinations and want 25 g of protein per can without sugar or caffeine.
Not ideal for: People avoiding dairy-derived protein or shoppers who prefer familiar citrus, cherry, or less distinctive flavors.
- Flavor:Banana Pineapple
- Protein:25 g per can
- Protein type:Whey protein isolate
- Can size:16 oz
- Pack size:12 cans
- Sugar:Zero sugar
- Caffeine:Caffeine free
- Carbonation:Lightly carbonated
Our verdict“Choose Banana Pineapple if you want Bucked Up’s 25 g protein format in a tropical flavor and are comfortable with whey.”
Proda Protein Soda Variety Pack, 10g Whey Protein, Zero Sugar
Proda is the flexible everyday pick for shoppers who want a sparkling protein drink without committing to one flavor. Each ready-to-drink serving supplies 10g of complete whey protein with zero sugar, and its caffeine-free formula fits occasions when an energy boost is not the goal. Compared with Bucked Up Berry Blast, Proda offers less protein per serving, but the variety pack gives buyers more flavor choice than a single-flavor case. It also avoids artificial sweeteners, a useful distinction for people who dislike their taste, though that alone does not guarantee a preferred flavor profile. Its modest protein amount makes it better as a light snack or soda substitute than as a full post-workout protein serving. It still contains whey, so it does not suit dairy-protein avoidance.
Pros:- Provides 10g of complete whey protein per serving
- Zero sugar and described as low calorie
- Caffeine-free and made without artificial sweeteners
- Variety pack offers more flavor choice than single-flavor cases
Cons:- 10g of protein is less than the 15g in Premier Protein Sparkling Protein Soda and the 25g in Bucked Up Berry Blast
- Contains whey, so it is unsuitable for people avoiding dairy proteins
Best for: Shoppers who want a caffeine-free, zero-sugar sparkling drink with 10g of whey protein and multiple flavors in one pack.
Not ideal for: People seeking a higher-protein serving like Bucked Up Berry Blast, or anyone avoiding dairy-derived whey.
- Protein:10g complete whey protein per serving
- Sugar:0g
- Caffeine:Caffeine-free
- Sweeteners:No artificial sweeteners
- Dietary attributes:Gluten-free, lactose-free, non-GMO
- Format:Ready-to-drink sparkling soda
- Pack:Variety pack
Our verdict“Choose Proda if you want a varied, caffeine-free zero-sugar protein soda for lighter everyday sipping rather than a high-protein serving.”
Bucked Up Lightly Carbonated Protein Soda – Berry Blast, 25g Whey Isolate, Zero Sugar, Low Calorie, Caffeine-Free, 12-Pack 16 oz Cans
Bucked Up Berry Blast leads this group on protein per can, delivering 25g of whey isolate in a 16 oz serving. That amount puts it closer to a substantial protein drink than Proda or SkyPop, each of which supplies 10g, while the light carbonation gives it a soda-like alternative to a conventional shake. Zero sugar and no caffeine make it a practical fit for people who want protein without either of those additions. The tradeoff is the larger can: 16 oz may feel like a lot alongside a meal or immediately after training, and the description does not provide an exact calorie count. This pack also sticks to Berry Blast, unlike Proda’s variety format, so it is a less flexible choice for shoppers who want to rotate flavors.
Pros:- Delivers 25g of whey isolate per can
- Zero sugar and caffeine-free
- Light carbonation offers a soda-style alternative to traditional shakes
- 12-can pack is convenient for keeping ready-to-drink servings on hand
Cons:- The 16 oz can is larger than the 12 oz Premier Protein Sparkling Protein Soda
- Pack contains only Berry Blast, with no flavor variety
- Exact calorie count is not specified
Best for: Active adults who want a ready-to-drink, zero-sugar option with a higher protein serving and do not mind a 16 oz can.
Not ideal for: Shoppers who prefer smaller cans, multiple flavors per case, or a conventional still protein drink.
- Protein per can:25g whey isolate
- Can size:16 oz (473 ml)
- Pack quantity:12 cans
- Sugar:0g
- Calories:Low; exact amount not specified
- Caffeine:None
- Carbonation:Lightly carbonated
- Flavor:Berry Blast
Our verdict“Pick Bucked Up Berry Blast if protein per can matters more than can size or flavor variety.”
SkyPop Protein Soda (12 Pack, Ice Pop)
SkyPop’s clearest advantage is its stated 45 calories per serving, paired with 10g of whey protein and zero sugar. That makes it a straightforward choice for buyers who want a light, sweet-style soda alternative but are tracking calories. It also skips caffeine, gluten, artificial flavors, and artificial colors, giving it a shorter list of stated exclusions than many flavored drinks. Compared with Premier Protein Sparkling Protein Soda, SkyPop has fewer grams of protein but no listed sugar; Premier offers 15g per 12 oz can and includes 3g of sugar. The Ice Pop flavor gives this 12-can pack a defined flavor identity, not the flexibility of Proda’s variety pack. The main limitation is its 10g serving, which may be too small for someone choosing soda primarily as a higher-protein shake substitute.
Pros:- Provides 10g of whey protein per serving
- 45 calories per serving with zero sugar
- Free of caffeine and gluten
- Made without artificial flavors or colors
Cons:- Offers less protein per serving than Premier Protein Sparkling Protein Soda and Bucked Up Berry Blast
- Contains whey, so it is not suitable for vegans or people avoiding dairy proteins
- The 12-can pack features only Ice Pop flavor
Best for: Calorie-conscious shoppers who want a caffeine-free, zero-sugar sparkling drink with a modest amount of whey protein.
Not ideal for: People looking for 15g or more of protein per can, a variety case, or a vegan protein source.
- Protein per serving:10g whey protein
- Calories per serving:45
- Sugar:0g
- Gluten:Gluten-free
- Caffeine:Caffeine-free
- Artificial flavors and colors:None
- Pack size:12 cans
- Flavor:Ice Pop
Our verdict“Choose SkyPop if a stated 45-calorie, zero-sugar profile matters more to you than a larger protein serving or flavor variety.”
Premier Protein Sparkling Protein Soda, Black Cherry, 15g Protein, 12-Pack
Premier Protein sits between the lighter 10g sodas and Bucked Up’s 25g cans, offering 15g of complete whey protein isolate in a 12 oz can. That middle ground may suit shoppers who want more protein than Proda or SkyPop without the larger 16 oz serving from Bucked Up Berry Blast. Its Black Cherry flavor and crisp sparkling format position it as a soda-style choice, while the five-ingredient recipe avoids artificial flavors and colors. The compromise is a small amount of sugar: each can has 3g, unlike the zero-sugar options in this lineup. Cane sugar and stevia also create a different sweetness profile that may not work for everyone. Compared with SkyPop, Premier brings 5g more protein per can but has more sugar and no stated calorie figure.
Pros:- Provides 15g of complete protein from whey protein isolate
- 12 oz can is smaller than Bucked Up Berry Blast’s 16 oz format
- Caffeine-free and sparkling
- Made with five ingredients and no artificial flavors or colors
Cons:- Contains 3g of sugar per can, unlike the zero-sugar Proda and SkyPop options
- Sweetened with stevia, which may not suit all tastes
- Contains whey and is not suitable for people avoiding dairy proteins
Best for: Buyers who want more than 10g of protein in a familiar 12 oz can and are comfortable with a small amount of sugar.
Not ideal for: Strict zero-sugar shoppers, people who dislike stevia, or anyone avoiding whey-based dairy protein.
- Flavor:Black Cherry
- Protein:15g per can
- Protein source:100% whey protein isolate
- Sugar:3g per 12 oz can
- Serving size:12 oz
- Ingredients:5
- Sweeteners:Cane sugar and stevia extract
- Caffeine:Caffeine-free
- Pack size:12 cans
Our verdict“Choose Premier Protein if you want a 15g protein serving in a 12 oz sparkling drink and accept 3g of sugar.”
How We Picked
I compared the 14 listed products using buyer-facing details available in their supplied names and descriptions: stated protein per can, sugar or calorie claims, caffeine information when provided, pack format, and flavor range. I gave more weight to how well each option serves a clear use case than to flavor names alone. A higher protein figure can suit shoppers seeking a more substantial protein drink, while lower-protein choices may appeal to those who care more about variety or a lighter stated calorie count.
The order reflects those differences, not a claim that every product was independently taste-tested. Bucked Up Peach Mango ranks first for its stated 25g protein and zero sugar; Livvy and Premier offer 15g formats with different advantages, while mixed packs and smaller packs earn attention for choice and trial flexibility. Where the supplied details do not list nutrition or caffeine information, I avoid filling in the gaps and recommend checking the product label. Flavor preference remains personal, so the guide also weighs how much commitment each pack requires.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Protein Sodas
Protein soda labels can make products with very different nutrition profiles seem interchangeable. I’d start by matching the can to your intended use, then check the label and pack details before choosing a flavor or buying a larger quantity.
Match Protein Per Can to Your Actual Goal
The products here range from 10g in Proda to 25g in Bucked Up, a difference large enough to affect how you use the drink. If you want a protein supplement to contribute a substantial portion of your intake, compare grams per full can rather than relying on the word “protein” on the front. A lower amount may still fit when the drink is an add-on or you prefer smaller servings. Don’t compare a can with a scoop or a standard shake without checking serving sizes. If you track daily intake, use the nutrition panel’s serving information, not just the pack description. Protein source can matter too: the Bucked Up options specify whey isolate, while details for other products should be confirmed on their labels.
Read Sugar, Calories, and Sweetener Details Together
Zero sugar does not mean identical nutrition, and it does not tell you which sweeteners create the taste. Compare total calories, total carbohydrates, and the ingredient list alongside the sugar line. Livvy lists 80 calories and low sugar, while several Bucked Up flavors are described as zero sugar; those claims serve different shopping priorities and should not be treated as a direct substitute for the full label. If you are sensitive to certain sweeteners or dislike a candy-like finish, ingredients and a small trial pack may matter more than headline macros. Check whether the nutrition panel refers to the full can. A drink’s sweetener profile can shape whether you enjoy it often, even when its protein numbers look appealing.
Choose Carbonation and Flavor for How You’ll Drink It
Protein soda has to work as a drink, not only as a nutrition product, so flavor and fizz are part of the decision. Names such as Frosted Lemonade, Green Apple, Rainbow Candy, and Orange Cream suggest very different taste directions, but the name alone cannot tell you how sweet, tart, or intense the drink will seem. If you usually prefer familiar fruit flavors, a fruit-forward option may feel like a safer start than a candy-style profile. Carbonation can also affect when a can appeals to you; some shoppers may prefer a fizzy drink with a meal, while others may want something less bubbly after exercise. Check whether the product is described as lightly carbonated or sparkling, and treat that wording as a cue rather than a precise measure. When flavor preference is uncertain, a mixed pack can be a more sensible first purchase than committing to 12 cans of one flavor.
Decide Whether Variety or a Single Flavor Matters More
Single-flavor packs simplify repeat buying, but they also leave little room to change your mind. Most Bucked Up entries in this roundup come in 12-can packs of one named flavor, making them a better fit when you already know what you like. Gym Soda, Livvy, and Proda offer variety formats, which spread the risk across multiple flavors but may include options you enjoy less. Before buying, check exactly which flavors are included; a “variety pack” does not mean every flavor will suit your palate. Also compare the total number of cans and the stated serving size, since pack names can make formats look more alike than they are. If you are new to protein soda, a smaller pack such as Clean Simple Eats’ listed four-pack can limit leftovers if the flavor is not for you.
Check Caffeine and Dietary Details on the Label
Caffeine-free is useful when timing matters, but the supplied product details do not state caffeine information for every option. If you plan to drink a can late in the day or avoid caffeine, verify the current can label instead of assuming a soda-style drink contains none. The same approach applies to allergens and dietary preferences: Bucked Up identifies whey isolate, which is milk-derived, so it is not a fit for someone avoiding dairy proteins. Product formulations can change, and short product titles do not show every ingredient or warning. Read the package for allergens, sweeteners, and any other ingredients you need to avoid. This label check is especially helpful when choosing among similar-looking options with different protein sources or flavor systems.
Compare Pack Commitment, Not Just Can Count
A 12-pack is convenient for a flavor you already enjoy, but it can be a poor first test if you are unsure about carbonation or sweetness. Smaller packs lower the cost of a flavor mistake in practical terms, even without comparing prices, while variety packs let you sample several profiles in one purchase. Look at the number of cans, can size, and servings together; a 16-ounce can is a different commitment from a 12-ounce can. Storage space and how quickly you expect to drink the pack may matter as much as the nutrition panel. For a first purchase, prioritize a manageable format; for a regular routine, a single flavor can be simpler if you know it suits you. Confirm the exact pack contents on the current listing, since product configurations may vary.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which protein soda in this roundup has the most protein per can?
Bucked Up’s listed flavors with 25g of whey isolate have the highest stated protein amount among these options. That makes them a strong match if protein per can is your main filter, but it does not automatically make them the best fit for every routine. Compare the full nutrition panel, can size, and ingredient list with your daily needs. If you prefer a lower stated calorie count or a mixed-flavor pack, Livvy may suit you better despite listing 15g protein. Check the package label for the exact flavor and current serving information.
Should I choose a variety pack or a single-flavor 12-pack?
A variety pack makes more sense when you are still learning which flavor profile you like, since it avoids committing to a full case of one option. Gym Soda, Livvy, and Proda are listed as variety packs, while many Bucked Up choices are single-flavor packs. A single-flavor case can be more convenient once you have a dependable favorite, but it is less forgiving if the sweetness or flavor is not right for you. Compare the exact flavors included before ordering; “variety” does not guarantee a balanced mix for your preferences. If you are particularly uncertain, the listed four-pack from Clean Simple Eats is another lower-commitment format to check.
Are all of these protein sodas caffeine-free?
No—the supplied details do not confirm caffeine status for every product. Some entries explicitly identify a flavor or product as caffeine-free, including Livvy and certain Bucked Up listings, but that information should not be generalized to the rest. If you avoid caffeine or plan to drink one near bedtime, inspect the current ingredient and nutrition information on the can or product listing. Formulas and labels can change, so the package is a more reliable guide than a flavor name. Also check for other ingredients you may need to limit or avoid.
Is zero sugar enough to tell me which option is right for my diet?
No; zero sugar is only one part of the nutrition picture. Check calories, carbohydrates, serving size, sweeteners, and the full ingredient list to see how a can fits your preferences. This roundup includes Bucked Up options described as zero sugar as well as Livvy, which is listed as low sugar with 80 calories. Those descriptions do not provide a complete side-by-side nutrition comparison. If you track a particular nutrient or avoid certain sweeteners, use the current can label rather than relying on a front-of-pack claim. Your overall diet and intended serving matter too.
What should I check before buying a full case of a flavor I have never tried?
Start with pack commitment, flavor style, and serving size. A 12-can case of one flavor gives you less flexibility than a mixed pack or a smaller format, so it may be a poor first choice if you are unsure about sweetness or carbonation. Look for a four-pack or variety pack where available, then check the listed can size and the exact flavor lineup. Read the ingredient list as well if you have dietary restrictions or strong preferences about sweeteners. Once you find a flavor you enjoy, a larger single-flavor pack may be more convenient for repeat use.
Conclusion
For the best overall balance of protein and stated sugar profile, I’d start with Bucked Up Peach Mango: it lists 25g of whey isolate and zero sugar, though its single-flavor 12-pack suits buyers who are comfortable committing. For value-minded shoppers who want flavor choice rather than the highest protein figure, compare the variety packs from Gym Soda, Livvy, and Proda, checking the current pack contents and label. My pick for a premium-style, lighter-protein option is Premier Protein Black Cherry if a familiar single flavor and 15g protein match your needs. For beginners, Livvy’s three-flavor pack or Clean Simple Eats’ listed four-pack offers a more measured way to find a flavor you like. For specific needs, choose Bucked Up’s 25g options when protein is the priority, Livvy when its stated 80 calories and low-sugar positioning appeal, and a clearly labeled caffeine-free option when avoiding caffeine matters. Check the current label before you buy, especially for caffeine, allergens, and nutrition details.
NFL season / tailgating Picks
team gear
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
